Apple Bungles Bluetooth in Mac Pro

(When I wrote this article in late October 2006, I assumed that Apple would eventually discover the problem and fix it. After all, there are many posts on Apple’s Support discussion boards about this issue. But, no; I get one or two emails a week from readers who have Mac Pros and have the same problem. I’m astounded that Apple still hasn’t fixed this–in fact, it is clear that the problem is not just in factories, because this morning I received an email from a reader who had the Bluetooth module installed (and wired incorrectly) in an Apple Store.

One more thing. I had the motherboard of my Mac Pro changed last week–there was a problem with USB ports. The technician who came to change it was the same one who walked me through the wiring change for the Bluetooth module over the phone–see below for more on my change. He was very interested to see which wires went where; when he took out the motherboard, it was very clear: the wire that had been originally connected to the Bluetooth module was the one that ran to the AirPort antenna at the back of the computer.)

When I got my new Mac Pro, I was delighted to have such a fast, quiet, powerful new Mac. I was also very happy to be able to use it with my recently-bought Mighty Mouse, which is one of the nicest input devices I’ve used yet. So to do this, I had to order the Bluetooth module, which is a build-to-order option on the Mac Pro. Alas, Apple bungled very badly, connecting the wrong wire to the Bluetooth module. But I’m not the only person who has had this problem; it seems endemic. Read on to find out the whole story…I started wondering what was wrong when my mouse skipped across the screen. Tracking was, at times, normal, but at others it was jerky. I’m right-handed, and the mouse is to the right of my keyboard; the Mac Pro is on the floor, just next to my desk, at a distance of about three feet. It’s in a kind of bookcase, and there’s a desk between it, but the bookcase is open at the front and back, so those two pieces of particle board couldn’t be blocking the Bluetooth transmission, so I thought.

Since I have AppleCare on the Mac Pro, I called the support team. They made me go through the usual motions–run a hardware test, reinstall the Mighty Mouse software, try another user account, and do a clean install. (Note that this was about two hours of my time to get a EUR 39 Bluetooth module and EUR 69 Mighty Mouse to work together…) Nothing resolved the problem, so they determined that there was a problem with the Bluetooth module and/or antenna, and told me a technician would get back to me to set up an appointment. AppleCare here offers on-site repairs for desktop Macs, and that’s one of the reasons why I always buy such contracts: living in rural France, the nearest Apple repair center is a few hundred kilometers away.

The next day, the technician who would come and make the repairs called to make sure he understood the problem, and to say he was ordering the parts. Yesterday (about a week after he ordered the parts) he called to say he would be coming today to make the repair. But in the meantime, I had looked around and seen, on Apple’s discussion boards, that other users were having the same problem. Not only was the problem the same, but a solution was offered.

Here’s where we get to the bungling on Apple’s part… The Bluetooth module is a small chip placed on the motherboard, and it has to be connected to a tiny wire that runs to the Bluetooth antenna. This wire is one of four, three of which are labeled: one has a “BT” label (this is a sticker that wraps around the wire), one is labeled “2”, and another “3”. For some reason, there is a fourth wire which is unlabeled.

The 2 and 3 wires are shorter than the BT and unlabeled wires: they are just long enough to reach the location where and AirPort card would be added. (I don’t have AirPort, so they’re not connected.) The other two wires (BT and unlabeled) are the same length; both can reach the Bluetooth module. So the solution proposed was to switch the BT wire for the unlabeled wire; as the posters in the thread linked to above have all said, this resolves the problem.

So here’s the rub: what happened is that two wires got mislabeled. This didn’t happen when the Bluetooth module was added to the computer, but during the actual assembly of the Mac Pro. This means that either all of Apple’s process sheets have an error, or only some Mac Pros are affected. It’s hard to know which: not every Mac Pro purchaser will get the Bluetooth module, so they won’t have a problem unless they add one later. Also, since the Mighty Mouse works at a distance of about two feet, many users may not realize that there is a problem: it seems that the module itself, and whatever that wire is connected to, emits enough power to work at short distances. (Whereas Bluetooth is speced to work at up to 10 meters or 30 feet.) These users may, however, have occasional problems, and write them off as battery issues or interference.

This has already cost Apple a bit of money, in support calls, and in exchanging Mac Pros, which they seem to have done in some cases, as well as keyboards and mice. The technician who was to come and change my Bluetooth module was especially glad that I could fix the problem (I did it while he walked me through it on the phone), because he had a total of five hours’ drive to my house and back.

Apple’s quality control has failed here. It’s pretty simple to mislabel one of two similar wires (though I haven’t yet found what the purpose of the other wire is), but to allow a machine to go into production without that being discovered is surprising. Again, this may only be the case on a limited number of Mac Pros, or it could affect all of them.

Apple, if you’re reading this, you’d better resolve the problem in your factories, and you had better then contact everyone who has bought a Mac Pro with a Bluetooth module. Save your time, and save ours–two hours the first time, then another hour yesterday to make the fix (going slowly, with the technician on the phone, to make sure I didn’t screw anything up) is far more time than I need to spend on a mistake that is the result of ineptitude. I grant that mistakes happen, but I’m tired of spending so much time to resolve them, simply because you haven’t found them yet.

July 2010: I still get emails about this, and comments are posted to this article, so apparently there are still issues with Bluetooth on Mac Pros. I sold mine more than a year ago – not because of the Bluetooth issue, but because I wanted to downsize (I got a Mac mini) – so I can’t help those who post asking for more help.

Here’s a link to a site that shows some pictures, which, if I recall correctly, match what I saw in my Mac Pro.

More info, Sept. 2010: A reader has pointed me to the following information that he posted on his web site. He solved the problem using a third-party Bluetooth dongle.

102 thoughts on “Apple Bungles Bluetooth in Mac Pro

  1. Thanks for this tip. I have a Mac Pro 2,1 but had never used the factory installed BT module until I bought a Magic Mouse a few days ago. Needless to say, its performance was uninspiring (jittery and jumpy and nearly useless) until I found your hint and performed the wire swaps. Now both the Air Port and BT works very well.

  2. Thanks for this tip. I have a Mac Pro 2,1 but had never used the factory installed BT module until I bought a Magic Mouse a few days ago. Needless to say, its performance was uninspiring (jittery and jumpy and nearly useless) until I found your hint and performed the wire swaps. Now both the Air Port and BT works very well.

    • @Eolake: The issues with the first gen Mac Pros (v 2,1) are the wires. Apparently, the new generations have a different cause of their BT connectivity problems. You might want to visit the Apple Support Forums to catch up on the efforts to find a solution. So far it seems Apple has nto acknowledged a problem–this could be that it is external interference or there could be a problem iwth a small number of systems. A lot of the people jsut gave up and bought an external USB BT dongle and that fixed it for them although it has other issues. There are 7 pages of posts. Bon courage!

      http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2231119&start=0&tstart=0

    • @Eolake: The issues with the first gen Mac Pros (v 2,1) are the wires. Apparently, the new generations have a different cause of their BT connectivity problems. You might want to visit the Apple Support Forums to catch up on the efforts to find a solution. So far it seems Apple has nto acknowledged a problem–this could be that it is external interference or there could be a problem iwth a small number of systems. A lot of the people jsut gave up and bought an external USB BT dongle and that fixed it for them although it has other issues. There are 7 pages of posts. Bon courage!

      http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2231119&start=0&tstart=0

  3. Hey Kirk. You’re a legend.
    Using the unlabelled one fixed it.
    Now my designer can use her BT mouse.
    Many, many thanks.

  4. Hey Kirk. You’re a legend.
    Using the unlabelled one fixed it.
    Now my designer can use her BT mouse.
    Many, many thanks.

  5. @Dd: I suspect you are right mine is now unplugged and Airport and BT work flawlessly and teh Airport range is better as well.

    @Kirk: with a small effort you have done a great deed for many. thank you. Sorry to hear aoubt you DL disc issue, I had 2 supper drives in my Mac Pro 2,1 and one of them was flaky. I always buy Apple Care so Apple Service made a house call to my home office and replaced it free. Over the last two years, they also had to replace the main board last year (One DRAM bank’s red LED wouldn’t turn off and I was worried about ECC problems), and they replaced the ATI X1900 card which failed. I always buy Apple Care–cheapest insurance policy against costly repairs in the industry. If your original warranty hasn’t run out, you can still extend it with Apple Care–if you can you should do it.

    • Daniel: I sold my Mac Pro last year and downgraded to a Mac mini. I did have Apple Care, and they came to me house twice for different issues.

      • Nice. I still use a Mac Pro 8-core because I need the horse power for video and 3DFX work and a both it and a Macbook Pro for SW development but my wife and daughters use iMacs and Macbooks. I recommend a Mac Mini for switcher friends as the least expensive way to move over. Sorry to hear of your problems. Apple has been first in reliability and quality consistently in surveys for years now but they do fall down sometimes.

        And you live in (or near) Paris you lucky dog.

  6. @Dd: I suspect you are right mine is now unplugged and Airport and BT work flawlessly and teh Airport range is better as well.

    @Kirk: with a small effort you have done a great deed for many. thank you. Sorry to hear aoubt you DL disc issue, I had 2 supper drives in my Mac Pro 2,1 and one of them was flaky. I always buy Apple Care so Apple Service made a house call to my home office and replaced it free. Over the last two years, they also had to replace the main board last year (One DRAM bank’s red LED wouldn’t turn off and I was worried about ECC problems), and they replaced the ATI X1900 card which failed. I always buy Apple Care–cheapest insurance policy against costly repairs in the industry. If your original warranty hasn’t run out, you can still extend it with Apple Care–if you can you should do it.

    • Daniel: I sold my Mac Pro last year and downgraded to a Mac mini. I did have Apple Care, and they came to me house twice for different issues.

      • Nice. I still use a Mac Pro 8-core because I need the horse power for video and 3DFX work and a both it and a Macbook Pro for SW development but my wife and daughters use iMacs and Macbooks. I recommend a Mac Mini for switcher friends as the least expensive way to move over. Sorry to hear of your problems. Apple has been first in reliability and quality consistently in surveys for years now but they do fall down sometimes.

        And you live in (or near) Paris you lucky dog.

    • I cannot argue with that–Paris has always been great to visit, but it would be even better to live in the Alps (see the Tour de France every year, skiing, hiking, etc) and one can always take the TGV into Paris for a bit of the bright lights, history, architecture, etc. when one needs a fix.The last time I took the TGV it was quite a nice ride–wish we had those in the States.

    • I cannot argue with that–Paris has always been great to visit, but it would be even better to live in the Alps (see the Tour de France every year, skiing, hiking, etc) and one can always take the TGV into Paris for a bit of the bright lights, history, architecture, etc. when one needs a fix.The last time I took the TGV it was quite a nice ride–wish we had those in the States.

  7. Any update on the 2009 Nehalem Mac Pro BT issues? I love my mighty mouse, but I just upgraded from a 2006 Mac Pro (thank you for the article, by the way! BT was frustrating until I read it and swapped wires) to a 2009 Nehalem, and the BT card and Airport card are on entirely opposite sides of the motherboard, with no way for the antennae to stretch/reach! I downloaded all the updates and read all the threads (disheartening that Apple refuses to acknowledge that it has a problem… the only ones they are hurting are their clients!!), and I am out of options… go back to a windows mouse or mighty mouse, or live with lag =/

    any help would be appreciated!!

  8. Any update on the 2009 Nehalem Mac Pro BT issues? I love my mighty mouse, but I just upgraded from a 2006 Mac Pro (thank you for the article, by the way! BT was frustrating until I read it and swapped wires) to a 2009 Nehalem, and the BT card and Airport card are on entirely opposite sides of the motherboard, with no way for the antennae to stretch/reach! I downloaded all the updates and read all the threads (disheartening that Apple refuses to acknowledge that it has a problem… the only ones they are hurting are their clients!!), and I am out of options… go back to a windows mouse or mighty mouse, or live with lag =/

    any help would be appreciated!!

  9. None from me–I am still on that aging Mac Pro 8-core and BT is working well with the Magic Mouse. I’ll be getting a Magic Pad one of these days.

  10. None from me–I am still on that aging Mac Pro 8-core and BT is working well with the Magic Mouse. I’ll be getting a Magic Pad one of these days.

  11. You, my friend, are an absolute genius.
    It was a bit of a fiddle, and I’m not 100% convinced the airport lead is connected fully, but I don’t use that anyway (certainly not very often). Had this problem since new and it’d always frustrated me. Now I can take my trackpad and keyboard to the sofa and away I go with the TV!
    THANK YOU so much for taking the time to share your knowledge. You’ve made my day, and made the internet an even better place!
    Cheers.

  12. You, my friend, are an absolute genius.
    It was a bit of a fiddle, and I’m not 100% convinced the airport lead is connected fully, but I don’t use that anyway (certainly not very often). Had this problem since new and it’d always frustrated me. Now I can take my trackpad and keyboard to the sofa and away I go with the TV!
    THANK YOU so much for taking the time to share your knowledge. You’ve made my day, and made the internet an even better place!
    Cheers.

  13. YES! THANK YOU VERY MUCH. this had been driving me NUTS since I moved the machine into the closet. I actually ordered a dongle but it just confused the thing even more so I ended up opening the thing up and trying my luck. i didnt even have a BT wire (2006) but the #1 wire seems to be working like a charm! the hardest part is geting that antenna connector snapped back into place. dont try doing it while slouched over on the floor! thats all i can say!? THANKS FOR MAKING ME WASTE MY SATURDAY SJOBS!

  14. YES! THANK YOU VERY MUCH. this had been driving me NUTS since I moved the machine into the closet. I actually ordered a dongle but it just confused the thing even more so I ended up opening the thing up and trying my luck. i didnt even have a BT wire (2006) but the #1 wire seems to be working like a charm! the hardest part is geting that antenna connector snapped back into place. dont try doing it while slouched over on the floor! thats all i can say!? THANKS FOR MAKING ME WASTE MY SATURDAY SJOBS!

  15. Thank you, thank you, thank you, and thank YOU!

    Has been driving me nuts for sooooo long. Was about to give up and get another mouse, and stumbled across your page.

    You are legend!

  16. Thank you, thank you, thank you, and thank YOU!

    Has been driving me nuts for sooooo long. Was about to give up and get another mouse, and stumbled across your page.

    You are legend!

  17. I bought a 1,1 Mac Pro second hand. Hard to believe these machines are 12y old! Bluetooth was frustrating, and I chalked it up to old hardware. However, on a particularly difficult mouse-ing experience, I decided to troubleshoot the problem and see what google said.

    Your recommended wire swap method fixed EVERY bluetooth issue. I tested the range and it shows no sign of failure far out as 20 feet away. Further than that and I can’t see the monitor well enough to asses.

    You are a legend!
    Thank you.

  18. I bought a 1,1 Mac Pro second hand. Hard to believe these machines are 12y old! Bluetooth was frustrating, and I chalked it up to old hardware. However, on a particularly difficult mouse-ing experience, I decided to troubleshoot the problem and see what google said.

    Your recommended wire swap method fixed EVERY bluetooth issue. I tested the range and it shows no sign of failure far out as 20 feet away. Further than that and I can’t see the monitor well enough to asses.

    You are a legend!
    Thank you.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.