Apple’s Home Sharing: Why is troubleshooting it so painful?

One of the most useful elements of Apple’s “digital hub,” at least for media like music and movies, is Home Sharing. This feature allows you to share your content across your local network to computers, iOS devices, and Apple TVs. However, it is not without its problems. It can be difficult–even impossible–to get Home Sharing to work on certain devices. Or Home Sharing may work for a while, then stop working. Problems are incredibly hard to diagnose with any networking feature, but Home Sharing is especially prickly.

A correspondent recently had a problem with Home Sharing, and it was quite difficult to troubleshoot. He was trying to use the Remote app on an iOS device to control iTunes on one of his Macs, and, while this had worked flawlessly for years, it suddenly stopped working. (The Remote app uses Home Sharing to connect to and control other devices.) He saw his Mac and Apple TV in the Remote app, but when he tapped either of them, he was unable to connect. He then attempted to re-pair the iOS device with the Mac, a process which requires typing a four-digit code that the iOS device displays in iTunes, but that failed as well.

The real problem was that there was no indication of what wasn’t working. And when we discovered the actual problem, it was actually quite simple, but there should have been some guidance.

Read the rest of the article on Macworld.

6 thoughts on “Apple’s Home Sharing: Why is troubleshooting it so painful?

  1. Unfortunately, “hard to debug” is true of most of Apple’s services. I’m not sure which is worse, “An error has occurred” or “Error -3231” Neither provides any information about what happened, let alone how to fix it.

  2. Unfortunately, “hard to debug” is true of most of Apple’s services. I’m not sure which is worse, “An error has occurred” or “Error -3231” Neither provides any information about what happened, let alone how to fix it.

  3. I agree that Home Sharing is terribly hard to debug. Posts on various help forums generally label it “a network issue”, as if that somehow clarifies the problem – it doesn’t. The usual advice is to restart all devices, which sometimes helps. Perhaps I can offer an additional observation.

    My iTunes library is on my iMac hard drive. I keep a copy of the library on a Synology NAS. I frequently stream films from the Synology device to an iPad, using Synology video-streaming software. It works flawlessly. When I stream the exact same film from my iMac (via iTunes) to my Apple TV, I often get the spinning wheel of death. Films often just won’t play.

    Because the same film (exact file copy) streams fine from Synology, I don’t belief the Apple issue is a network issue – at least not in the sense of it being a router or bandwidth issue. I think the problem is inherent in the Apple home sharing software. So much for my two cents (or two pence) …

    • I don’t think this addresses the same issue, but I’ve noticed trying to load my “Home Shared” iTunes library with my 3rd gen (old style connector) iPad causes iTunes on the Pad to hang. Guess it can’t swallow my large library.

  4. I agree that Home Sharing is terribly hard to debug. Posts on various help forums generally label it “a network issue”, as if that somehow clarifies the problem – it doesn’t. The usual advice is to restart all devices, which sometimes helps. Perhaps I can offer an additional observation.

    My iTunes library is on my iMac hard drive. I keep a copy of the library on a Synology NAS. I frequently stream films from the Synology device to an iPad, using Synology video-streaming software. It works flawlessly. When I stream the exact same film from my iMac (via iTunes) to my Apple TV, I often get the spinning wheel of death. Films often just won’t play.

    Because the same film (exact file copy) streams fine from Synology, I don’t belief the Apple issue is a network issue – at least not in the sense of it being a router or bandwidth issue. I think the problem is inherent in the Apple home sharing software. So much for my two cents (or two pence) …

    • I don’t think this addresses the same issue, but I’ve noticed trying to load my “Home Shared” iTunes library with my 3rd gen (old style connector) iPad causes iTunes on the Pad to hang. Guess it can’t swallow my large library.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.