iWant: Time Machine for iOS

I wrote yesterday how I lost data stored in iCloud, and had to get geeky to retrieve it. This shouldn’t happen. Ever. With Dropbox, for example, if you have two files with the same name, Dropbox saves both of them, showing, in the file names, that there is a conflict. And back in the days of pre-iCloud syncing, Apple showed you when there were conflicts and let you resolve them. But now, iCloud, in an attempt to be as transparent as possible, has eliminated such features.

Data is important; data integrity is essential. There is simply no situation where losing data is acceptable. Yet, for many people who use iCloud, this is the case.

The data loss I described is not uncommon. I’ve heard from lots of people who’ve had similar problems with Apple’s app and with third-party apps. The best Apple can do is tell you how to find missing information in iCloud after restoring an iOS device; they talk about apps, media, messages, but not data that has been lost. About two years ago, a number of app developers spoke out about this, and some app developers have given up on iCloud because of its lack of reliability.

iOS can back up to iCloud automatically. But this isn’t a real backup; it only stores some settings, but not most data. It stores pointers to apps and purchased content, but not content that you’ve synced to the device that Apple doesn’t sell. It’s not a backup, it’s not even a clone; it’s a selective backup of what Apple is concerned about. Apple’s logic is probably that iCloud will still have your app data: your contacts, calendars, notes and more. But as I, and many others have seen, iCloud can lose data. Also, you may have apps that store data locally; that don’t sync to the cloud, that don’t store files on Dropbox. In that case, it’s very hard to recover lost data.

Apple created Time Machine for the Mac so users would be protected. It’s still users’ responsibility to turn it on, and to purchase an external hard drive for the backups, but it’s not Apple’s fault any more if users don’t back up their data.

Apple needs to create Time Machine for iOS. This would back up what is backed up now, but also all the data that Apple’s apps and third-party apps store. You should be able to go back and see previous versions of this data and restore it, as you can with Time Machine.

There is no excuse for iCloud losing data. Apple needs to create a safety net so this never happens.

12 thoughts on “iWant: Time Machine for iOS

    • It’s all or nothing. And, unless you manually back up to iTunes (by clicking the Back Up Now button), iTunes only saves one backup.

    • It’s all or nothing. And, unless you manually back up to iTunes (by clicking the Back Up Now button), iTunes only saves one backup.

  1. I agree with you completely, Kirk. It’s ridiculous, that the standard backup system, iCloud, doesn’t back up many of the things that the user creates. It backs up (sets pointers to) my Apps??!!! Those things that Apple already takes care of, which can always be downloaded again, most of which contain little or no data that I would really care about. This is like an insurance policy, which covers damage to your house, but making sure their offices are safe and warm, so you will be comfortable when you come in to ask why they denied your claim.

    You can also back up to your computer. According to the AppleCare people that I have talked to, this also doesn’t create a complete backup. My understanding is that you can’t create a complete backup, nor a clone, nor can you delete the gigabytes of junk that iOS accumulates. The only way to get rid of that junk, according to AppleCare, is to erase your phone and do a restore. This is usually the second or third step that AppleCare suggests, and they always say, “you won’t lose anything.” When I tell them a short list of what I know I will lose, they seem surprised, but unconcerned.

  2. I agree with you completely, Kirk. It’s ridiculous, that the standard backup system, iCloud, doesn’t back up many of the things that the user creates. It backs up (sets pointers to) my Apps??!!! Those things that Apple already takes care of, which can always be downloaded again, most of which contain little or no data that I would really care about. This is like an insurance policy, which covers damage to your house, but making sure their offices are safe and warm, so you will be comfortable when you come in to ask why they denied your claim.

    You can also back up to your computer. According to the AppleCare people that I have talked to, this also doesn’t create a complete backup. My understanding is that you can’t create a complete backup, nor a clone, nor can you delete the gigabytes of junk that iOS accumulates. The only way to get rid of that junk, according to AppleCare, is to erase your phone and do a restore. This is usually the second or third step that AppleCare suggests, and they always say, “you won’t lose anything.” When I tell them a short list of what I know I will lose, they seem surprised, but unconcerned.

    • That still doesn’t back up user data. Whether you back up via Wi-Fi or USB connection, it doesn’t change anything.

    • That still doesn’t back up user data. Whether you back up via Wi-Fi or USB connection, it doesn’t change anything.

  3. I have a 128GB iPhone 6. Time Macine would be ideal. Thought about using one of those online petition sites to get a large number of people backing the request to Apple?

  4. I have a 128GB iPhone 6. Time Macine would be ideal. Thought about using one of those online petition sites to get a large number of people backing the request to Apple?

Leave a Reply to Kirk McElhearn Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.