The Ergonomics of the iPad Pro

Ipad pro

Apple started selling the iPad Pro today, and reviews are pouring in from the usual sources. I was very interested in John Gruber’s review on Daring Fireball. Gruber seems to be the only person who has addressed the problems of using Apple’s keyboard with the iPad Pro. He says:

Trying to use the iPad Pro as a laptop with the Smart Keyboard exposes the seams of an OS that was clearly designed for touchscreen use first. These seams aren’t new — I’m sure anyone who has tried using an iPad of any sort with a paired Bluetooth keyboard has run into the same things. This is simply the first time I’ve tried using an iPad with a hardware keyboard for an extended period for large amounts of work.

While there are some keyboard shortcuts that let you interact with the iPad – such as Command-Tab to switch applications – there are many operations you cannot do from the keyboard. Gruber points out how difficult it is to launch applications. You can use the Command-space shortcut to go to your home screen, but:

you still have to pick your arm up and touch the screen to launch the app.

And you can search for an app, but:

you can’t use the keyboard arrow keys to navigate the list of results.

Add to this the lack of a trackpad or other pointing device. I assume you can tap the display with Apple’s Pencil – the stylus designed for the iPad Pro – but you’ll still need to raise your arm and touch the screen a lot, which will eventually lead to shoulder pain.

I suggested to John Gruber that he could use Siri to launch apps, but he pointed out that the Hey Siri feature only works when the device is connected to a power source. So, while you can tell Siri, for example, to Open Mail on an iPhone, you cannot use this voice control on the iPad Pro. It seems that the iPad Pro (and other iPads) is crying out for a Siri keyboard shortcut.

Another thing I notice with Apple’s keyboard is its rigidity. I don’t think you can change its angle, and it doesn’t look like it would be as good on your lap as an actual laptop. It seems designed for the desktop only. And since you can’t change the angle of the iPad when using that keyboard, you’ll be frozen into a position that may not be ideal for long work sessions. It seems like a recipe for neck pain.

You can, of course, use the iPad Pro with an external Bluetooth keyboard, including Apple’s new Magic Keyboard, and lean it on a third-party stand. This makes it more flexible when working on a desk. And some third party keyboards make make it adapted to actual “laptop” use. But as the iPad Pro stands today, with Apple’s keyboard – which, by the way, isn’t shipping for 3 to 4 weeks – it doesn’t look like it can replace a computer for ergonomic working.

10 thoughts on “The Ergonomics of the iPad Pro

  1. I use a lot of drawing and touch-based music apps so I plan to get an iPad pro. I am waiting for more reviews of the new Smart Keyboard before I decide to submit my order.

    When using the iPad like a laptop with a keyboard case, an iFaraday stylus inserted in an aluminum Derwent artist’s pencil holder makes touching screen icons much easier, I don’t even have to lift my arm off of the desk. The stylus and holder extend to up 10 in. (25cm) for a long reach.

  2. I use a lot of drawing and touch-based music apps so I plan to get an iPad pro. I am waiting for more reviews of the new Smart Keyboard before I decide to submit my order.

    When using the iPad like a laptop with a keyboard case, an iFaraday stylus inserted in an aluminum Derwent artist’s pencil holder makes touching screen icons much easier, I don’t even have to lift my arm off of the desk. The stylus and holder extend to up 10 in. (25cm) for a long reach.

  3. Does the Apple Pencil allow text entry via handwriting? That’s not shown as a feature on the websites.

    I have to say as someone with both iOS and Android devices, the iPad Pro looks a bit like my Samsung Galaxy Note 12.2, except with that device, the stylus is included, can be stored in the tablet and doesn’t require charging!

    Robert

    • I don’t think so.

      Your Samsung uses a different type of stylus; the Apple stylus is designed to interact with the screen, which makes it more precise.

      • Yes, I’m aware the Samsung stylus is different (for one thing it’s quite small), but it’s hard to see another stylus being more precise than it is. I get to vary shading and thickness when drawing. I can use it for text entry and I don’t have to charge the stylus (it picks up charge by induction from the screen). Actually the handwriting recognition of the Note series is why I have a Note 4 and the Galaxy Note 12.2, and why my iPad usage has dropped recently.

        One thing – those who say that the size of the iPad Pro is a major disincentive are going to be wrong, at least for many use cases. The multi windowing possible in the Samsung and in the iPad Pro is very useful, for example. I also don’t find the big Samsung tablet particularly unwieldy, so I’d be surprised if that was an issue for the iPad Pro .

  4. Does the Apple Pencil allow text entry via handwriting? That’s not shown as a feature on the websites.

    I have to say as someone with both iOS and Android devices, the iPad Pro looks a bit like my Samsung Galaxy Note 12.2, except with that device, the stylus is included, can be stored in the tablet and doesn’t require charging!

    Robert

    • I don’t think so.

      Your Samsung uses a different type of stylus; the Apple stylus is designed to interact with the screen, which makes it more precise.

      • Yes, I’m aware the Samsung stylus is different (for one thing it’s quite small), but it’s hard to see another stylus being more precise than it is. I get to vary shading and thickness when drawing. I can use it for text entry and I don’t have to charge the stylus (it picks up charge by induction from the screen). Actually the handwriting recognition of the Note series is why I have a Note 4 and the Galaxy Note 12.2, and why my iPad usage has dropped recently.

        One thing – those who say that the size of the iPad Pro is a major disincentive are going to be wrong, at least for many use cases. The multi windowing possible in the Samsung and in the iPad Pro is very useful, for example. I also don’t find the big Samsung tablet particularly unwieldy, so I’d be surprised if that was an issue for the iPad Pro .

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.