The iPad Awkwardly Turns 10 – Daring Fireball

Ten years later, though, I don’t think the iPad has come close to living up to its potential. By the time the Mac turned 10, it had redefined multiple industries. In 1984 almost no graphic designers or illustrators were using computers for work. By 1994 almost all graphic designers and illustrators were using computers for work. The Mac was a revolution. The iPhone was a revolution. The iPad has been a spectacular success, and to tens of millions it is a beloved part of their daily lives, but it has, to date, fallen short of revolutionary.

[…]

Software is where the iPad has gotten lost. iPadOS’s “multitasking” model is far more capable than the iPhone’s, yes, but somehow Apple has painted it into a corner in which it is far less consistent and coherent than the Mac’s, while also being far less capable. iPad multitasking: more complex, less powerful. That’s quite a combination.

Consider the basic task of putting two apps on screen at the same time, the basic definition of “multitasking” in the UI sense. To launch the first app, you tap its icon on the homescreen, just like on the iPhone, and just like on the iPad before split-screen multitasking. Tapping an icon to open an app is natural and intuitive. But to get a second app on the same screen, you cannot tap its icon. You must first slide up from the bottom of the screen to reveal the Dock. Then you must tap and hold on an app icon in the Dock. Then you drag the app icon out of the Dock to launch it in a way that it will become the second app splitting the display. But isn’t dragging an icon out of the Dock the way that you remove apps from the Dock? Yes, it is — when you do it from the homescreen. So the way you launch an app in the Dock for split-screen mode is identical to the way you remove that app from the Dock. Oh, and apps that aren’t in the Dock can’t become the second app in split screen mode. What sense does that limitation make?

[…]

How would anyone ever figure out how to split-screen multitask on the iPad if they didn’t already know how to do it?

Multitasking on the iPad is one of those things that 2% of people will use, because only, say, 10% bother to figure out how it works, and most of them will find it too unwieldy to use. (Yes, I’m estimating, for rhetorical reasons…) While I think it’s great that Apple has forked iOS to create an iPad specific version, it’s too complicated to use these features.

I don’t use my iPad a lot, but I know there are people who use it as their main computing device. While some of them leverage every possible feature of multitasking, shortcuts, etc., most probably just use a one-app-at-a-time approach. Why? Because it’s not confusing. When I have used multitasking, I’ve never felt that I accomplished any app-arranging actions by anything other than luck.

It’s not Apple’s fault that they couldn’t come up with a better system, it’s just the limitations of the device and its interface. If they want people to use these features, they need to figure out a way to make them easy to use, and, above all, easy to discover.

Source: Daring Fireball: The iPad Awkwardly Turns 10

3 thoughts on “The iPad Awkwardly Turns 10 – Daring Fireball

  1. The initial split screen interface was actually ok. As I recall, you’d resize size the app onscreen by swiping from the right to create an empty space. The next app you opened would open in the empty space. It was much more intuitive and easier to use. I never understood why they changed it, and I haven’t used split screen much sine they did.

  2. This is heresy! But your right 😉 BTW I’ve owned many iPad’s from the first through the 2018 Pro. Mostly handing down to the family as the new improved ones came out.

    I love my 2018 iPad Pro, and I think iPad OS 13 is a good but tiny, tiny step in the right direction. For instance if I want to use a mouse it is a total pain is the posterior.

    As pointed out the multiple windows use seems very awkward, and should be made easier to use and manipulate with different apps.

    The rumors of an improved keyboard for the next iPad Pro, assuming it is true, would also be most welcome.

  3. For the last six months I have been trialling using a new Ipad Pro as an alternative to a Macbook Air. So ran head-on into the multitasking problem, among others. Eventually, I have relapsed back into using the iPad the same way I use my iPhone. Then I don’t have to think about the device when I am concentrating on the task in hand.

    Forking away from the iOS interface has, in my opinion, resulted in a very unfocused design – neither one thing nor the other, with multiple ways to achieve a result. The latter has always been a fault with Windows UI design, now the iPad is in the same place. Apple’s traditional simplicity, elegance and attractiveness have all been lost.

Leave a Reply to Robert Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.